Got a bill you didn't expect? Learn when balance billing is illegal under federal law and New York's even stronger protections — and what your options are.
You went to an in-network facility. You did everything right. Then a bill arrived for hundreds — or thousands — of dollars you weren’t expecting. Sound familiar? You’re not alone, and you may not actually owe that money.
Balance billing is one of the most misunderstood areas of healthcare finance. Patients often pay bills they’re legally not required to pay simply because they didn’t know the rules. This post explains when balance billing is illegal, how federal law and New York’s protections compare, and what it means specifically if you’re receiving physical therapy on Long Island. By the end, you’ll know your rights — and what to do if someone is violating them.
Balance billing happens when a provider charges you the difference between what your insurance paid and what the provider originally billed. For example, if a provider charges $1,000 for a service and your insurer’s allowed amount is $250, a balance bill would ask you to cover the remaining $750 — on top of whatever cost-sharing you already owe.
That practice is legal in some situations and explicitly illegal in others. The line depends on who treated you, where, whether you had a genuine choice in the matter, and which state you live in. In New York, that last factor matters more than most patients realize.
The No Surprises Act was signed into law on December 27, 2020, and took effect January 1, 2022. It was designed to protect the more than 200 million Americans covered by private health insurance from unexpected bills in situations where they had little or no control over which provider treated them.
Under the Act, balance billing is illegal in three core scenarios. First, emergency services — if you go to an emergency room, you cannot be balance billed for emergency care regardless of whether the facility or any of the treating providers are in your network. Second, non-emergency services from out-of-network providers at in-network facilities — this is the situation that catches most people off guard. You choose an in-network hospital for a scheduled procedure, but an out-of-network anesthesiologist, radiologist, or other specialist is involved without your knowledge. Before 2022, that provider could send you a bill for the full gap. Now, they generally cannot. Third, air ambulance services from out-of-network providers are also covered under the Act’s protections.
The key concept is that you couldn’t have reasonably chosen otherwise. When the provider was selected for you — not by you — the law steps in. What the Act does not cover is a situation where you knowingly and voluntarily chose an out-of-network provider, were informed of the cost, and signed a valid consent form acknowledging it. That’s a narrow exception, and it comes with specific requirements that providers must meet before that waiver is enforceable.
One thing worth knowing: the No Surprises Act does not cover ground ambulance services at the federal level. If you received a surprise bill from a ground ambulance, federal law won’t help you there. New York’s law, however, does offer some protections in that area — which brings us to why your state of residence matters so much.
New York didn’t wait for federal action. The state passed the nation’s first surprise medical billing law back in 2015 — seven years before the No Surprises Act took effect nationally. That head start means New York residents have a more comprehensive safety net than most Americans, and understanding how the two laws interact is important if you live in Suffolk County or Nassau County.
Under New York’s law, you’re protected from surprise bills when you’re treated by an out-of-network provider at a participating hospital or ambulatory surgical center that is in your plan’s network. You’re also protected when a participating doctor refers you to a non-participating provider — a scenario the federal law doesn’t address as directly. Emergency inpatient care following an ER visit is covered too, even if the follow-up providers are out of network.
When state and federal law conflict, the standard that gives you more protection as a consumer is the one that applies. In practice, that often means New York’s law provides the floor — and it’s a higher floor than what federal law sets on its own.
One area where this distinction is especially relevant on Long Island is ground ambulance billing. The federal No Surprises Act leaves ground ambulance services out of its protections entirely. New York’s law fills part of that gap. If you received an unexpected bill from a ground ambulance service after an emergency in Suffolk or Nassau County, the state’s rules may offer you recourse that federal law does not.
Another area that’s often overlooked entirely is no-fault auto insurance. New York requires all drivers to carry no-fault coverage, and physical therapy is one of the most commonly billed services after a car accident. Under Section 5108(a) of the New York Insurance Law, charges for professional health services covered under no-fault — including physical therapy — cannot exceed the applicable fee schedule. If a PT provider bills you above that schedule after a car accident, that is a billing violation. Many patients don’t know this, and some billing companies operating in New York aren’t fully aware of it either. If you’ve been in an accident on Long Island and are receiving physical therapy, your billing rights in that context are specific, documented, and enforceable.
Want live answers?
Connect with a Medcare Therapy Services expert for fast, friendly support.
The term “balance billing protection act” gets used loosely to refer to both the federal No Surprises Act and various state-level statutes, including New York’s. Understanding what these laws actually cover — and where the gaps are — is the difference between paying a bill you don’t owe and successfully disputing one.
Both the federal and state frameworks share a common principle: patients should not be penalized financially for receiving care from providers they did not choose. But the details of what’s covered, who enforces it, and how you file a complaint vary depending on which law applies to your specific situation.
This is one of the most common questions patients have, and the confusion is understandable. If your provider is in-network, can they still send you a balance bill? The short answer is no — and the longer answer explains why it’s not just a rule, it’s a contractual and legal prohibition.
When a provider joins an insurance network, they agree to accept the insurer’s negotiated rate as payment in full. That means they cannot bill you for the difference between their standard charge and what the insurer paid. Doing so would violate their network contract and, depending on the circumstances, applicable law. For Medicare participating providers, it goes further — federal law explicitly prohibits balance billing Medicare patients above the Medicare-approved amount. There is no gray area there.
Where it gets more complicated is the in-network facility, out-of-network provider scenario. You chose an in-network hospital, but an out-of-network specialist was part of your care. That specialist is not bound by the hospital’s network contract. Before 2022, they could bill you directly. After the No Surprises Act, that billing is restricted — the most you can be charged is your in-network cost-sharing amount for that service. The out-of-network provider and your insurer then resolve the payment dispute through a process called independent dispute resolution, which happens entirely behind the scenes without involving you.
The practical takeaway: if your provider is in-network and you’ve paid your applicable co-pay, coinsurance, or deductible, a balance bill on top of that is almost certainly not something you’re legally required to pay. You should contact your insurer first, then, if needed, the New York Department of Financial Services, which is the state agency responsible for handling surprise billing complaints in New York.
Yes — balance billing by participating providers is prohibited, and it’s worth understanding exactly what “participating provider” means in this context because the term matters legally.
A participating provider is one who has entered into a contract with an insurer or a government program to provide services at agreed-upon rates. For Medicare, that means the provider has accepted assignment and agreed to bill only the Medicare-approved amount. For commercial insurance, it means they’ve signed a network participation agreement. In both cases, billing the patient for any amount above what that agreement allows is a violation — of the contract, and often of the law.
This is relevant for physical therapy patients specifically. If you’re receiving PT at a clinic that participates in your insurance plan, and you’ve paid your applicable cost-sharing, any additional bill for covered services is not legitimate. If you receive one, don’t assume you owe it. Start by calling your insurer and asking them to clarify what they paid and what your responsibility actually is. Get that in writing if you can.
If you believe a participating provider has illegally balance billed you in New York, you have options. You can file a complaint with the New York Department of Financial Services at dfs.ny.gov. For issues involving Medicare, complaints go through the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The New York Attorney General’s office also actively enforces surprise billing protections in the state.
One important nuance: consent forms. Providers can, in limited circumstances, ask you to waive balance billing protections for non-emergency, non-ancillary services where you had a genuine choice of provider and were informed of the costs upfront. But these waivers are narrow and cannot be used for emergency care, for ancillary services like anesthesiology or radiology at in-network facilities, or in situations where you had no realistic alternative. If you signed something at intake and are now being told you waived your rights, it’s worth verifying whether that waiver was actually valid under the circumstances.
If you’ve received a bill that doesn’t look right, don’t pay it out of fear and don’t ignore it. Start by calling your insurer and asking for an explanation of benefits — a breakdown of what was billed, what they paid, and what they say you owe. Compare that against what you were told before treatment. If the numbers don’t add up, or if you were never informed that an out-of-network provider would be involved, you likely have grounds to dispute it.
New York residents have some of the strongest billing protections in the country, and those protections exist whether you received care at a hospital in Smithtown, a clinic in Holbrook, or through an in-home physical therapy visit anywhere across Suffolk or Nassau County. The rules are on your side — you just have to know they exist.
If you’re looking for a physical therapy provider on Long Island who accepts Medicare and most commercial insurance plans, handles no-fault rehabilitation, and is straightforward about what you’ll owe before treatment begins, we’re here to help. Reach us at 631-866-6507.
Summary:
Article details:
Share: