Prefer In-Office Treatment? Visit One of Our Locations

When Medical Bills Are Illegal and How to Fight Back

You thought it was covered. Then the bill arrived. Here's what the law says about surprise medical bills — and what you can actually do about them.

You need physical therapy. Your doctor referred you. But you haven’t called yet — because you’ve heard the stories. Someone thought their insurance covered it, then got a bill weeks later for hundreds of dollars they weren’t expecting. So you wait, hoping the problem resolves on its own.

That waiting is costing you. And here’s the part nobody tells you: a lot of those surprise bills were already illegal when they were sent.

Federal law and New York State law both protect patients from unexpected medical bills in ways that most people simply don’t know about. Let’s walk through what those protections actually cover — and what to do if a bill lands in your mailbox that shouldn’t have.

No Surprise Billing Law: What It Actually Covers

The No Surprises Act became federal law on January 1, 2022. Before that date, patients could legally be billed by out-of-network providers they never knowingly chose — an anesthesiologist at an in-network hospital, a specialist called in during a procedure, an emergency physician at a facility their insurance covered. The bill would arrive weeks later, with no warning and no recourse.

The law changed that. For care received on or after January 1, 2022, providers are prohibited from billing you more than your in-network cost-sharing amount in several specific situations. If you went to an in-network emergency room, an in-network hospital, or an in-network ambulatory surgical center, and an out-of-network provider was involved in your care without your knowledge — that provider cannot send you a balance bill. Your insurance handles the rest.

Since the law took effect, it has protected Americans from more than 10 million surprise medical bills in the first nine months of 2023 alone, according to a joint survey by AHIP and the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association.

What the Medical Surprise Billing Law Does Not Cover

Understanding what the law covers is important. Understanding what it doesn’t cover is equally important — because that’s where patients still get caught off guard.

The No Surprises Act does not apply to every billing situation. If you knowingly and voluntarily choose to see an out-of-network provider at an out-of-network facility, the law’s protections don’t automatically apply. In that scenario, a provider can bill you at out-of-network rates — but only if they gave you a proper written notice and you signed a separate consent form acknowledging the cost. That consent form must be a standalone document, not buried inside general intake paperwork. Signing an admission form does not constitute consent to surprise billing.

The law also does not apply to non-emergency services at out-of-network facilities when you’ve been informed and genuinely agreed. The word “genuinely” matters here. The consent has to be real, documented, and specific — not implied or slipped past you in a stack of forms.

If you’re on Medicare or Medicaid, the No Surprises Act does not apply to you directly. That’s not because you’re unprotected — it’s because Medicare and Medicaid already have their own separate balance billing protections built into the program. If you’re a Medicare patient receiving physical therapy, your protections come from Medicare’s rules, not the NSA. Knowing which set of rules applies to your situation matters when you’re trying to figure out whether a bill is legitimate.

New York State adds another layer on top of all of this. New York had its own surprise billing law in place before the federal version, administered by the New York Department of Financial Services (NY DFS). Long Island residents are covered by both — a double layer of protection that most people don’t know about until they need it.

Your Right to a Good Faith Estimate Before Care Begins

One of the most practical protections in the law is also one of the least known: the Good Faith Estimate. Under the No Surprises Act, if you are uninsured or paying out of pocket, any healthcare provider — including physical therapists — is required to give you a written cost estimate before your care begins. This isn’t optional, and it isn’t just a courtesy. It’s a legal requirement.

The estimate must be provided at least one business day before a scheduled service. If you schedule more than three days in advance, you’re entitled to it at least three days out. The estimate has to include the expected charges for each service, any associated items or procedures, and the provider’s name and location.

Here’s where it gets actionable: if the bill you receive is $400 or more above the estimate you were given, you have the legal right to dispute it. You don’t have to pay the difference while the dispute is pending. You have 120 days from the date you receive the bill to initiate the process through the federal Patient-Provider Dispute Resolution system. The No Surprises Help Desk at (800) 985-3059 is available seven days a week, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern, and can walk you through it.

For New York patients specifically, the NY DFS runs a parallel complaint process. You can reach them at (800) 342-3736 or by email at su******************@****ny.gov. If a provider in Suffolk County or Nassau County sends you a bill that violates state or federal surprise billing rules, these are the people to call.

Want live answers?

Connect with a Medcare Therapy Services expert for fast, friendly support.

How to Fight an Unexpected Medical Bill Step by Step

Getting a bill you didn’t expect doesn’t mean you have to pay it. It means you have a decision to make — and the law gives you real tools to make it.

The first step is to slow down. Billing errors are common, and many surprise bills are the result of a coding mistake, a missed insurance submission, or a provider who wasn’t aware of your coverage. Before you dispute anything formally, call the provider’s billing department and ask them to verify that the claim was submitted correctly and that your insurance information was applied. Sometimes the problem resolves at this stage.

If it doesn’t, you move to the formal process — and that process has teeth.

How to Dispute a Medical Bill in New York

New York patients have a distinct advantage: the state’s own surprise billing law, combined with the federal No Surprises Act, gives you two separate avenues for recourse. You don’t have to choose one or the other — you can pursue both.

Start by documenting everything. Pull together the Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from your insurance company, the bill from the provider, and any written estimate or cost disclosure you received before care. If you were given a consent form related to out-of-network billing, include that too. The more documentation you have, the stronger your position.

If the bill involves an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility — the classic surprise billing scenario — your insurance company is required to handle the dispute with the provider directly under the Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process. You should not be in the middle of that negotiation. Your cost-sharing amount is capped at what your in-network plan would have required, and it stays there regardless of what the provider and insurer work out between themselves.

If you’re uninsured or self-pay and the bill exceeds your Good Faith Estimate by $400 or more, you file through the federal Patient-Provider Dispute Resolution system. The filing fee is $25. An independent arbitrator reviews the case and makes a binding decision. You have 120 days from the bill date to initiate this process — don’t let that window close.

For New York patients whose situation falls under state law rather than federal (or both), the NY DFS IDR portal handles the state-level process. The NY DFS also accepts complaints directly and can intervene with providers who are violating the law. Long Island residents dealing with a billing dispute from a provider in Suffolk or Nassau County can use the state process even if the federal process doesn’t apply to their specific situation.

A medical bill in dispute cannot be sent to collections while the dispute is active. Under recent federal guidance, medical debt has been removed from credit reports in many circumstances — meaning even if a bill does end up in collections, its impact on your credit score is more limited than it used to be.

What Transparent Billing Actually Looks Like from a Provider

The law sets a floor. What a good provider does is build well above it.

There’s a meaningful difference between a provider who hands you a consent form and a provider who actually explains your coverage before you ever schedule a session. The first one is technically compliant. The second one is the kind of provider you can trust.

We verify insurance benefits before your first appointment. That means you know what your coverage looks like, what your out-of-pocket responsibility is, and what to expect before any care begins. It’s not a promise buried in fine print — it’s how we operate, because we’ve seen what happens when patients are left to figure out billing on their own. They don’t get better. They don’t call back. They put off care that they genuinely need.

We serve patients across Long Island — in-home throughout Suffolk County and parts of Nassau County, and in-clinic at our Smithtown and Speonk locations. Whether a therapist comes to your home or you come to one of our offices, the billing relationship is direct and clear. There are no in-network facilities with out-of-network providers on staff. There’s no multi-provider complexity that creates unexpected billing entities. You work with one therapist, under one billing relationship, with no surprises.

For patients recovering from auto accidents, our no-fault rehabilitation capability means your treatment is billed under New York’s no-fault system. If you’re covered, you shouldn’t be paying out of pocket — and we know how to make sure that’s handled correctly from the start. For Medicare patients, our therapists are credentialed to deliver Medicare-covered services, and we’ll walk you through exactly what Medicare covers and what it doesn’t before you commit to anything.

We’ve been serving Long Island since 2000 at our Smithtown clinic and since 2010 for in-home care throughout Suffolk and Nassau County. That’s a long track record of learning what billing transparency actually requires — and of patients who came to us worried about costs and left with a clear picture of what they owed and why.

What to Do If You've Already Received an Unexpected Medical Bill

Don’t pay it automatically. Don’t ignore it either. Take a breath, gather your documents, and start with a call to the billing department to verify the claim was processed correctly. If that doesn’t resolve it, you have real legal options — both at the federal level and through the New York Department of Financial Services — and you have more time than you probably think to use them.

Billing fear shouldn’t be the reason you don’t get care you need. Nearly half of insured adults in the United States received a bill in 2023 for something they thought was covered. That’s not a personal failure — that’s a broken system that the law is now actively correcting.

If you’re on Long Island and you’ve been putting off physical therapy because you’re not sure what it’s going to cost, reach out to us at Medcare Therapy Services. We’ll give you a straight answer before you ever schedule a session.

Summary:

Unexpected medical bills are one of the most common — and most preventable — sources of financial stress in healthcare today. Federal law and New York State law both offer real protections that most patients don’t know exist until it’s too late. This post breaks down exactly what the law covers, where the gaps are, and how to dispute a bill you shouldn’t have received. If billing fear has ever stopped you from seeking care, what you’re about to read may change that.

Table of Contents

Request a Callback
Got it! What's the best ways to follow up with you?

Article details:

Share:

Where Would You Like to Receive Care?
Select the most convenient option for your therapy needs
In-Home Services
Personalized care delivered to the comfort of your home
Smithtown
Our flagship facility with state-of-the-art equipment
Speonk
Convenient East End location serving the Hamptons area