Received a medical bill you weren't expecting? Here's what New York law actually says about balance billing — and what you're legally protected from paying.
You finished your physical therapy sessions, felt good about your progress, and then the bill arrived — and it was nothing like what you expected. Maybe your insurance paid their share, and now the provider is asking you to cover the rest. Or maybe you were referred to someone you assumed was in-network, and it turns out they weren’t.
Whatever the situation, the first question is always the same: can they actually do this? The answer depends on the type of insurance you have, how you received care, and a few specific rules under New York law. Let’s walk through it clearly.
Balance billing happens when a provider charges you the difference between their full fee and what your insurance actually paid. So if a provider charges $500, your insurance pays $300, and the provider bills you the remaining $200 — that’s a balance bill. The question is whether that’s legal.
In New York, the answer is often no. Under the New York Surprise Bill Law, providers cannot bill you for more than your in-network cost-sharing — meaning your copay, coinsurance, or deductible — in certain situations. This applies when you unexpectedly receive care from an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility, or when your in-network doctor refers you to a provider who isn’t in your plan’s network without your explicit knowledge and consent.
Not every state handles this the same way. Across the country, 18 states have comprehensive balance billing protections in place, 15 have partial protections that only cover certain services or plan types, and 17 states have no specific state-level protections at all. New York falls into that first group — and it has for a while. The state’s Surprise Bill Law actually predates the federal No Surprises Act, which means New York was already ahead of the curve when Congress finally acted.
The federal No Surprises Act took effect on January 1, 2022, and it created a nationwide floor of protections that applies regardless of what state you live in. Under that law, health plans cannot deny coverage for emergency services just because you went out-of-network, and they cannot allow providers to balance bill you for most emergency care. It also limits what you can be charged when an out-of-network provider — like an anesthesiologist, radiologist, or pathologist — is brought in at an in-network facility without your choosing them.
For New York residents, this means you’re protected by two layers of law simultaneously. The state law covers situations where a participating doctor refers you to a non-participating provider, and the federal law covers emergencies and certain ancillary services. Together, they create a fairly comprehensive shield — but there’s one significant gap that matters a lot on Long Island, and we’ll get to that in a moment.
What’s important to understand right now is that “I didn’t know they were out-of-network” is actually a protected situation under New York law. If you didn’t choose that provider — if they were assigned to you, referred to you, or simply present at a facility you were already using — you generally cannot be held responsible for the difference between what they charge and what your insurance pays.
Here’s the part that most articles skip over, and it’s the part that affects a significant number of Long Island residents more than they realize. New York’s state-level Surprise Bill Law only applies to fully insured health plans — meaning plans where an insurance company is actually carrying the financial risk. It does not apply to self-funded employer plans, where the employer itself is paying the claims and simply using an insurance company to administer the plan.
This matters on Long Island because many large employers — particularly those with large workforces in industries like finance, healthcare administration, retail, and government — self-fund their employee health benefits. If your health insurance comes through your job and your employer self-funds the plan, New York State’s Surprise Bill Law does not protect you. Only the federal No Surprises Act applies in that scenario.
How do you know if your plan is self-funded? The most direct way is to call the member services number on your insurance card and ask. You can also look at your Summary Plan Description, which employers are required to provide. If it says the plan is “self-insured” or “self-funded,” you’re in federal-law-only territory for balance billing purposes.
This doesn’t mean you’re unprotected — the federal No Surprises Act still applies and covers emergency situations and certain out-of-network scenarios. But it does mean that some of the broader state-level protections New York offers won’t apply to your specific situation. Knowing this ahead of time is far better than finding out after you’ve already received a bill you weren’t expecting.
If you’re ever unsure whether a provider is in-network before starting physical therapy, the safest move is to ask before your first appointment — and to get a clear answer in writing if possible.
Want live answers?
Connect with a Medcare Therapy Services expert for fast, friendly support.
The No Surprises Act gets cited a lot, but there’s real confusion about what it actually covers for physical therapy specifically. It’s not a blanket ban on all unexpected medical bills — it targets specific scenarios where patients had no meaningful ability to choose their provider.
For physical therapy patients, the most relevant scenario is when you’re discharged from a hospital or surgical center and referred to a therapist who turns out to be out-of-network. If that facility is in your plan’s network and you didn’t independently select that therapist, the federal law limits what you can be charged to your standard in-network cost-sharing. The provider cannot bill you for the rest.
Medicare has its own set of rules around balance billing, and they’ve been in place long before the No Surprises Act. If a physical therapist accepts Medicare — meaning they’ve agreed to Medicare’s terms of participation — they cannot charge you more than the Medicare-approved amount for covered services. Full stop. The difference between what they billed and what Medicare paid is not your responsibility.
There are two categories of Medicare providers: participating providers, who accept Medicare assignment and agree to the approved amount as payment in full, and non-participating providers, who can charge slightly more but are still capped at a “limiting charge” set by Medicare. Providers who have opted out of Medicare entirely are a separate category and can set their own fees, but they’re required to give you written notice before treating you.
The practical takeaway for Medicare beneficiaries on Long Island: before starting physical therapy, confirm that the provider accepts Medicare assignment. A provider who does accepts the Medicare-approved amount as full payment, so your only out-of-pocket costs are your standard Medicare cost-sharing — typically your Part B deductible and 20% coinsurance, which may be covered by a supplemental plan.
At Medcare Therapy Services, we accept Medicare and nearly all commercial insurances. We verify your coverage before your first visit so you know what to expect — not after the fact when a bill has already arrived. For seniors across Suffolk County and Nassau County, that kind of upfront clarity is exactly what the Medicare billing landscape requires.
If you’ve received a bill that you believe violates New York’s Surprise Bill Law or the federal No Surprises Act, you have concrete options — and you don’t have to figure it out alone.
The first step is to contact the New York Department of Financial Services. The DFS is the state agency that enforces the Surprise Bill Law for fully insured plans, and they have a dedicated complaint line for exactly this situation. You can reach them at 1-800-342-3736 or by email at su******************@****ny.gov. They can review your situation, contact the provider or insurer on your behalf, and help resolve the dispute.
If your plan is self-funded through an employer, the DFS isn’t the right agency — that falls under federal jurisdiction. In that case, you’d contact the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) or the Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA), depending on the plan type. It’s worth noting that you generally don’t have to pay a disputed balance bill while the dispute process is ongoing, though you should confirm this with the agency handling your complaint.
One thing that’s worth clarifying: disputing a balance bill is not the same as disputing a copay or coinsurance. Your plan’s cost-sharing — the amounts you agreed to pay when you enrolled — is not a balance bill. A balance bill is specifically the amount a provider tries to charge you above and beyond what your insurance has already settled. If you’re not sure which category your bill falls into, call the member services number on your insurance card first and ask them to explain the Explanation of Benefits (EOB) line by line.
For auto accident patients specifically, New York is a no-fault state, which means your own auto insurance covers medical expenses including physical therapy regardless of who caused the accident. Under New York Insurance Law, no-fault providers are prohibited from billing you above the Workers’ Compensation Board fee schedule. If a physical therapy provider is billing you personally for treatment that should be covered under no-fault, that’s a red flag worth investigating.
The short version: New York gives you real, enforceable protections against balance billing — but those protections have limits, and knowing where those limits are is what keeps you from being caught off guard. If your plan is fully insured, you have both state and federal law working in your favor. If your employer self-funds your plan, the federal No Surprises Act still applies, but the state-level protections don’t. And if you’re on Medicare or covered under no-fault auto insurance, there are additional rules that cap what providers can charge you.
The best protection, honestly, is choosing a provider who handles this transparently from the start — one who verifies your insurance before your first visit, explains your cost-sharing clearly, and doesn’t leave you piecing together a confusing bill after the fact.
We’ve been serving Long Island patients across Suffolk County and Nassau County since 2010. If you have questions about coverage, billing, or whether we accept your insurance, call us directly at 631-866-6507. We’d rather answer your questions before your first appointment than leave you guessing afterward.
Summary:
Article details:
Share: